Monday, February 20, 2012

Harris on Countering



I appreciate that Harris addressed how current political debates are structured.  It’s almost as if he knew that I had just previously blogged about that.  Rather than forwarding, countering is what happens in most of the political scheme of things.  In countering, Harris explains that one can argue the other side, uncover values or dissent.  Arguing the other side consists of stating the benefits of something an author has criticized or the negatives of something an author has argued for.  This is probably the main part of countering.  Uncovering values is slightly different.  It doesn’t involve arguing against something the author said but rather something the author didn’t say.  It involves taking an undefined term in a text and analyzing it for greater meaning.  Dissenting is where you find a shared thought with the author and then you identify its limits.  Gizmodo, a blog that I often read for electronic and other news often uses countering.  Normally it doesn’t directly cite another author, say what he or she says and then argue the other side.  Rather countering on this blog comes in the form of one article arguing both sides of an argument.  Though the same author writes it, it seems to fit with countering.  Take this article that I read today on Googles’ new ‘Latitude Leaderboards’ which is a new program to let friends know where you are and see where they are.  (http://gizmodo.com/5886460/googles-latitude-leaderboards-is-a-blatant-foursquare-rip+off)  The author begins by offering its benefits but then goes on to say the other side of it that is that this program has already been created by many other sites.  In offering this information it provides both perspectives.  

Sunday, February 19, 2012

Forwarding Off of Harris

Harris begins with a good example, that in having a conversation with somebody, you rarely can convince him or her of your perspective by just refuting what he or she is saying.  Conversations require that you take what they have said and expand on it.  This expansion carries the subject matter on into new places and opens the mind of whom you’re talking to rather than just closing it to what they already know.  This is critically important with the reading and writing we are doing.  If we took what other authors said and simply pointed out everything they were saying as wrong, this would be a reply that would end the conversation.  Instead, as Harris mentions, we must forward their ideas and beliefs into new realms and add to them.  Mentioning faults and inconsistencies isn’t always a no-no so long as it is balanced out with comments that forward their writing on.  In a short little tangent, this is what I feel is wrong about politics these days.  Debates, political advertisements and other parts of politicians campaigns oftentimes focus on what their adversaries are doing wrong.  Rather than continuing the conversation into new places, adding to others thoughts and really opening up the political world to the public, they focus on scandals and mistakes.  This is why we are experiencing such slow progress in this country.  The democrats and republicans aren’t forwarding off of one another but simply replying.  This creates a static environment.  Returning to what we are doing in blogging we are commenting on the writing of others and continuing the conversation.  It is important for us to look at the works of others and forward their ideas by using examples, invoking their expertise, drawing on terms and putting our own spin on their concepts.  The New York Times as I discussed in a previous post forwards many ideas off of the White House Blog.  Information that comes out on the WHB for example on the budget then gets looked at by journalists at the Times and they draw on examples, use the expertise of quotes from the president, draw on terms and they even put their own political spin on the news.  Its interesting to see the tie in between the two.

Monday, February 13, 2012

A great example of the press sphere.


The top story on the left side of the New York Times homepage is “Obama Uses Budget to Set Election-Year Priorities.”  At the same time, the first post on the White House Blog is “The 2013 Budget.”  The New York Times article seems to focus on the upcoming election and how his new budget will help his campaign.  An important passage portrays the tone of the article: “The budget over all captures Mr. Obama’s effort to define the 2012 election not as a referendum on his record, which puts him on the defensive if unemployment does not continue to come down, but as a choice between his priorities and those of Republicans, who reject any higher taxes and want to sharply reduce the size of government and remake its most popular programs, Medicare and Medicaid.”  This contrasts the post on the White House Blog, which portrays the president’s interests, and perspectives on the new budget.  The blog tries to focus on what the budget will do for the middle class and attempts to give voters hope: “This year’s budget reflects the President’s firm belief that our country has always done best when everyone gets a fair shot, everyone does their fair share, and everyone plays by the same rules. It’s a document built around the recognition that this is a make or break moment for the middle class and those trying to reach it.”  The president focuses on the parts of the budget that target job growth, a reauthorization bill for roads, and how the economy will be boosted in the next year.  The New York Times read into all of this as the president setting up for his election year and campaign.  This is probably correct.  It’s interesting to think that the author of the NYT article might have read this blog.  If that were true it would be a great example of the press sphere.  The government/white house is represented directly by the white house blog and the NYT article represents the press.  Information from the government gives the press information for its news story.

Blog Analysis

White House Blog

Purpose - Essentially this serves to update readers on what the president, the first lady and other members of the cabinet are doing.  It contains articles on topics like the science fair held in the white house, the first lady's 'conversation on healthy eating,' and Obama's new budget.  It gives the president a direct, controllable outlet to release information.

Audience - The audience of this blog seems to be more to the side of Obama's supporters rather than his opponents.  It is for everyone to read, but the perspective of the blog seems very limited.  It seems to show only stories supporting what the president is doing.

Author - The authors are most likely Obama's staff members.  I doubt that Obama is writing this blog himself.

Materials and Methods - The blog contains videos of the president and others in the white house, quotes that the president made in statements and facts on legislation.  The methods used in writing seem to be writing about what the president has done recently and then sharing a video or quotes that inform the reader further.

Key Words - None that I noticed

Uses and Limits - This blog seems to be limited to what the president is doing.  Though it provides beneficial information on that it doesn't offer much perspective on other news outside the presidents circle and what is happening at the white house.

The Press Sphere Model


Jarvis approaches the shift in the distribution of information that has occurred.  He describes the change in how news organizations relate with readers, the government and companies.  The way that the media and its readers interact has changed.  Jarvis explains that the flow of information is no longer a one-way street.  Instead, news sources, archives, government, companies, witnesses and the press all share information back and forth.  Readers post links to background information, and a multitude of perspectives are shared in a story.  News coverage is no longer about a newspaper presenting the facts on an event or a topic.  With the Internet, it is a conversation between many organizations, people and interest groups.
I wasn’t really confused by this model; it actually made complete sense to me.  Though basic, it seemed to cover the way news and articles develop fairly well.
Looking at his rough sketch of the ‘press sphere’ model, I was reminded of a similar model from my political science class.  The cobweb model has many of the same groups in bubbles and it talks about how interests within the country come to compromise and maintain a balance in creating public policy decisions.  The overlap shows that people can be in both groups, which is the same as in Jarvis’s model.  Jarvis says, “Witnesses can join in the process directly. Background might come via links to archives.”  A member of the press can also be a witness or observer.  Meaning readers are also writers.  This ties into my relation with the news and becoming a blogger.  As we are reading more articles, we are also writing more.  The interplay between readers and writers on the Internet is much more prevalent then ever before.

Wednesday, February 8, 2012

Where in the world is President Obama?

I found number 44 on technorati's list of top blogs to be interesting.  It is the White House Blog.  This blog is hosted and controlled by the President's staff.  It updates readers on what the president and the rest of the cabinet is doing.  The most recent updates are on Michelle Obama and the science fair hosted at the white house.  It seems interesting to me because it will keep me informed on what the president is doing in relation to what is going on in the rest of the news.

My opinion on the Times

I've been quite used to reading the New York Times for a while now.  As I described in earlier posts, though I took a break from it last quarter, I did read it throughout most of high school.  The NYT is one of the most respected and influential news sources in the world, if not the most.  Even facing a society drifting away from print news sources, the NYT found a way to survive.  It revamped its business plan, putting all of its news online and beginning to cap the articles that you can read.  To access more than the headlines and a few articles, you now have to pay the subscription fee.
The stories that I remember reading most were ones about the current political environment and the republican primaries.  These seemed the most important to the days events.  Most of my reading went off of the home page, without venturing to the different sections of the world news.  In doing this I'm sure I missed interesting stories that for whatever reason didn't make the headlines.
What the New York Times does that I love is in articles it links to opinion pages and other interesting stories.  After skimming an article I can read related articles.  This leads me to read the different perspectives on an event as well as background information that I otherwise wouldn't have been exposed to.